I would think that they would check to see if your ID matches what they have for the current title, and would only issue a lost title to the person who they have listed as the current owner...
* 00 LC
* stinky old Ford Diesel tow rig (FOR SALE)
* 99 Saab Convertible
* 71 FJ40
* 64 FJ40 "Ocho Mater 40" AGAIN
* 74 FJ40 - parting out
has a 2008 FJC