Alright thanks guys, so that clinches it- my mileage sucks, at 50-60 miles before needing to hit the reserve. I didn't completely fill it though, trying to leave a little room at the top, but it was pretty close to full. I will get better at consistency there, and I finally figured out the trip odometer on the speedo thing so can do a better job of tracking that as well.
What was interesting was it was all at once- no sputtering, no hesitation, just went from running to off. Is that how your bike runs out of gas?